Skip to main content

The Killing Joke (2)

 1. What is your reaction to the text you just read?

Eh, it was kind of underwhelming. I'm already not a huge superhero fan, but I do think Batman is probably one of the comics I could probably get into the easiest because I think his dynamic with the Joker is interesting. Since it's an origin story of the Joker, I was really hoping it would clear up a lot more than it did. In fact, I think it didn't really clear anything up at all. It left me with more questions than answers. Why are you going to portray this in a way that relies heavily on mental instability and not approach it realistically? I don't mean this as in I was offended by it or anything, either. I purely mean it in a way that even from a superhero perspective, it was trying too hard to be meaningful and fell flat. It just didn't make sense. His wife dies, they literally do not bring her up ever again, the Joker barely shows emotion towards it, and then he falls into a radio active puddle?? And that's how he becomes THE JOKER? That is so laughably sad. Maybe this is because of my superhero bias, but if you're gonna make the story dark, at least put some thought into it.


2. What connections did you make with the story? Discuss what elements of the story with which you were able to connect?


I did not connect to it. I thought it was pretty lame. I also do not think the "one bad day" translates at all. "My wife died, I almost got shot because I'm an idiot and tried to join the mob and fell into goo. Therefore I will now kill other people because I'm crAaaAZAyyy," yeah I don't think that's good writing at all. It's fake deep. It's probably as shallow as the puddle was the Joker fell into. 



3. What changes would you make to adapt this story into another medium? What medium would you choose; what changes would you make?

Well, I think I would just write it better. Make it make more sense; I felt more connected to Deadpool's girlfriend dying than I did this, and I KNEW Deadpool was a parody. I think it would be fun as a movie, but they have Joker out already (Which I have not seen) that I'm assuming does what this tries to do a lot more successfully. If they're gonna make his origin story about the "one bad day", I would push that more. Add in the repercussions to his wife dying, him knowing he now truly has nothing left to live for. Make him a truly broken man being thrust into insanity. Make him be framed for the mob crime, make him feel hopeless, and THEN I can believe he's gone insane. He can still fall into the radiation, but make it disfigure him, make him have a reason to put his makeup on rather than being like "oh the radiation just happened to make him look like a clown lol." How disingenuous.



4. In what ways does this story differ from the typical expectations the reader might have for a superhero story?

I don't think it differed from my expectations in the fact that it just made me disappointed. It's not a very witty origin story. I like the addition of him buying a theme park and having the ability to make people die with a face like his, that's not a thing that needs explanation. I'm not even talking about him kidnapping the girl because it was so incredibly dry to me. Dry and boring.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Persepolis (6? Points)

  This story was extremely insightful. It’s best to read as an American since we are so ill-informed of other countries, especially Middle Eastern destinations. It was fascinating to learn about Persian culture and how it evolved just throughout Marjane’s life alone. By the end of the war, I was still a little confused how some women could be all dolled up with their hair visible and makeup on, but majorly had to stick to the regime other times. I think when Marjane met them they were hanging out in private, but I’m unsure. Either way, learning about the mental toll it took on our protagonist to have to mold yourself to fit in with different cultures at just 14 is unimaginable. I wasn’t surprised to see her indulge herself in drugs and get caught in depression later, it was such a hard thing for her to have to go through. Additionally, there’s A TON of political talk that I wasn’t fully understanding but got the gist for the most part. And yes, there’s also a lot I did not agree wi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Une Semaine de Bonte (1 Point)

 This one was very hard to translate because I was trying so hard to comprehend the pictures. Maybe it's because I'm having a hard time deciphering what's even in the photos due to lack of contrast in some of them. I definitely think it has something to do with livestock. I've heard that the Texas Chainsaw Massacre is an allegory for how awfully we treat pigs and cattle, and I feel like this might be going in the same direction, just with chickens. The chickens in almost every photo are torturing, stalking, scaring, or kissing humans. I think this is talking about how we treat livestock as pets, but will ultimately use them for what they're worth and end up culling them in the end. Even the kissing makes sense to me because people love their pets and kiss them all the time. I'm not a pet owner or a vegan/vegetarian, but I feel like that's what is being said here. It could also be a bit more general than that as well. It could just be talking about how humans...
Post a Comment
Read more

Nanking (6 Points)

  This piece was beautifully illustrated and written, and really knew how to pack a punch right to the heart-strings. The way they constructed the narrative of the little girl being the one to tie all of these people together is brilliantly done. Sadly, the story itself is not really an uplifting one.  I wasn't aware of what happened to other countries during WWII. When they taught us in school they spoke about only the bombing of Pearl Harbor and told us that the holocaust was the worst thing to happen in human history. But getting to know the finer details of things is really what makes us educated and I had no idea what was happening in the Eastern countries. I'm touched that at the end of Nanking, the woman says she forgave the Japanese for what happened because nothing good could come out of war anyway. But she had lost everything and everyone she had in that awful siege of Nanking. They may have took all she had that was left, but thankfully she had people who were there...
Post a Comment
Read more